State and local governments lost at least $117 billion of expected revenue early in the pandemic, according to an Associated Press analysis, but many are now awash in record amounts of money, boosted partly by federal aid.
In response to the dramatic turnaround, governors, lawmakers and local officials have proposed a surge in spending as well as a new wave of tax cuts.
“The ultimate effect of the pandemic was a net positive,” said Stephen Parker, assistant city manager for the Los Angeles suburb of Upland, where sales tax revenues are soaring. “Isn’t that unbelievable? It’s just crazy to think of that.”
Upland, a city of 79,000, was representative of many cities at the outset of the pandemic. It reported an estimated loss of nearly $6.1 million in 2020 — the result of a steep but short-lived national recession and what Parker describes as a “generous” Treasury Department method for calculating losses. That figure was the median amount among more than 900 cities that reported their revenues to the department under the American Rescue Plan Act.
People are also reading…
Upland’s financial situation turned around even before the end of 2020, Parker said. Federal COVID-19 stimulus checks played a role. So did a shift in consumer spending to goods instead of services. That lifted city revenues, Parker said, because services often are exempt from sales taxes, while goods are not.
The pandemic relief law championed by Democrats and signed by President Joe Biden last March included $350 billion in aid to states and local governments. The Treasury Department required states, counties and larger cities to file reports last year detailing their initial plans for the money. Those governments also were asked to estimate their losses for 2020 by comparing actual revenue to expected revenue under a Treasury formula.
Though revenue figures were left blank by nearly one-quarter of the roughly 3,700 governments that filed reports, the data nonetheless provides the most comprehensive picture yet of the financial strain on governments during the pandemic’s first year.
More than two-thirds of state and local governments reported at least some losses, ranging from a few thousand dollars in some rural counties to more than $12 billion for the state of Texas, according to the AP’s analysis. The total was $117.5 billion.
The Treasury Department last October declined an AP request to release the revenue-loss data under the federal Freedom of Information Act, saying it would be publicly available later. It recently posted the data on its website. The next reports are due Monday for some governments and April 30 for others.
Actual General Revenue – Actual General Revenue as of 12 months ended December 31, 2020
Base year – Revenue for the most recent fiscal year prior to the beginning of the coronavirus pandemic. For most governments, that meant their base year was the 2019 fiscal year.
Estimated loss – Estimated Revenue Loss Due to Covid-19 Public Health Emergency as of December 31, 2020
Funds allocation – Explanation of how revenue replacement funds were allocated Recovery funds for pension – Whether Fiscal Recovery Funds used to make a deposit into a pension fund
The report for North Carolina lists its 2020 revenue as $26.6 trillion and its base year revenue as $24.8 trillion. AP confirmed with the state that these figures were intended to be shown as billions, not trillions, and AP has updated the data accordingly.
There are 28 entities for which there appear to be data entry errors in the base year revenues. These entities show base year revenues of $2,016 or $2,019 or $2,020. It appears likely that these were intended to be base years of 2016, 2019 or 2020 but got entered into the wrong field.
The department used lost revenue to determine how much flexibility to give governments in spending the aid. Under guidelines issued last May, governments that showed a loss were free to spend an equal amount on almost any government services, including roads and other projects not otherwise allowed under the rules.
A final rule released earlier this month expanded that flexibility by allowing governments to claim up to $10 million of revenue losses, even if actual losses were less.
Upland, which is getting $15 million, plans to use part of its flexible spending to repave parking lots and repair hundreds of sections of sidewalks that might not otherwise have been eligible.
Federal assistance was not the only factor that helped governments bounce back.
Financial analysts also cite inflation, which pushed up prices and bolstered sales tax collections. Many consumers also had more to spend because of the stimulus checks. A strong stock market drove up capital gains taxes. And an early pandemic rise in unemployment spared many higher earners, who shifted to working from home while continuing to pay income taxes.
In many places, the revenue rebound exceeded pre-pandemic levels. Total state tax revenues from last April through November rose 20% compared to the same period in 2019, according to an Urban Institute report released earlier this month.
For governments that already were financially strained, the pandemic deepened their losses but also resulted in a cash windfall.
The Hudson River Valley city of Poughkeepsie was rated by the New York comptroller as the state’s most financially stressed community in 2020. With a pre-pandemic deficit around $7 million and no reserves, the city quickly cut spending, sold property, froze hiring and instituted an early retirement program “in a desperate effort to close the gap” when the pandemic began, City Administrator Marc Nelson said.
The city reported a 2020 revenue loss of nearly $4.5 million under the Treasury Department’s formula. It’s getting more than $20 million from the American Rescue Plan. Though the relief money cannot be used to wipe out the deficit, the city plans to make major improvements to parks and swimming pools, including a complete rebuild of a run-down bathhouse that has been relying on portable toilets.
“These are things that would not have been within the city’s ability to take on were it not for the COVID relief money,” Nelson said.
Though they’re spending the federal aid, some Republican officials insist it was unnecessary in light of the rapidly rebounding tax revenues.
Missouri reported an estimated $900 million loss for 2020 but ended its 2021 fiscal year with a record cash balance. Republican Gov. Mike Parson recently proposed a $47 billion budget that is up nearly one-third over the current year because of surging federal and state revenues. He wants to spend more on infrastructure and public employee salaries while also saving more.
“When other states will be using federal dollars to fill spending gaps and budget shortfalls, we will be making investments in the future,” he said in his State of the State address.
In some cases, government losses weren’t as severe as the Treasury numbers might suggest.
Greer County in rural southwest Oklahoma reported a 2020 revenue loss of $363,630 — around the national median for counties reporting their revenues. That comprised 10% of the county’s expected revenue under the Treasury Department formula, but it didn’t prompt budget cuts, County Clerk Tiffany Buchanan said.
“The county didn’t feel that much of a loss,” Buchanan said, explaining: “We live on a very tight, strict budget as it is.”
The county plans to use some of its $1.1 million from the American Rescue Plan to help fund the sheriff’s office and pay emergency medical personnel.
Some states, including California and Texas, projected large revenue losses at the outset of the pandemic but have since posted big gains.
When it passed a budget early in the pandemic, California had expected the recession to cause a $54 billion deficit. That led officials to defer payments to schools and community colleges and to reduce state employee pay, according to the state’s Treasury report.
Now California is projecting a nearly $46 billion surplus spurred by record tax collections, leaving officials searching for ways to use the money. Gov. Gavin Newsom recently proposed a budget that would expand health coverage to all low-income adults living in the state illegally while simultaneously cutting taxes. The Democratic governor also said a substantial tax rebate was likely in order.
“I will be holding the governor’s feet to the fire and keep him at his word to refund surplus dollars to the taxpayers,” GOP state Sen. Melissa Melendez said.
Images: After huge pandemic losses, governments see rapid rebound